CTPA panel urges context and consistency to counter beauty misinformation

Speakers from industry and government focused on everyday risk analogies, peer-review transparency and meeting uncertain consumers where they are.

Beauty scientists, regulators and communicators used the Cosmetic, Toiletry and Perfumery Association’s first scientific conference to examine how the industry can counter misinformation and build public trust. The members-only event, held at Central Hall Westminster in London earlier this month, brought government and industry speakers together to discuss scientific evidence, regulatory decisions and consumer understanding at a time of information overload.

In opening remarks, Caroline Rainsford, CTPA director of science, said strong science communication is essential because people in many roles must turn complex evidence into material audiences can understand. Later, on a panel about trust through science communication, she stressed the value of context. She recalled explaining to salon professionals that an ingredient banned from nail polish would require someone to wear about two kilograms of polish to approach the level associated with harm. Framing risk in everyday terms, she said, helps it resonate.

Everyday analogies and a single voice

Marc Pissavini, sun research lab director at Coty, endorsed that approach. He said an Olympic swimming pool can help convey the relevance of a liquid dose: at two litres a day, a person would need roughly 4,500 years to drink one pool. Once that is explained, he said, people can understand that a drop in a pool is very small. To fight misinformation, the first task is to explain and give consumers ways to measure and understand the issue, he added.

Pissavini also linked credibility to consistency and education. He argued that scientists, doctors, dermatologists and companies would be stronger if they spoke with one voice and used “we” rather than “I,” citing pharmacy and large groups as examples.

Peer review and where to engage

Wendy Middleton, chief scientific officer and director for science at the UK Office for Product Safety and Standards, said the idea of a single voice is worth exploring but noted that scientists are not especially good at it. Credible science depends on critique and peer review, she said, and the aim should not be to abandon that process but to become more aware of the profession and how its members communicate with one another.

Pissavini, who also edits the peer-reviewed International Journal of Cosmetic Science, said maintaining peer review is crucial. The difficulty, he said, lies in finding reviewers and in communicating better with readers both inside and outside the industry. Rainsford added that the sector needs to work collectively to demystify peer review, since many people—including some in the industry—do not understand how it works. Transparency about the process will be important, she said.

Listening before correcting

Claire Coleman, a journalist, editor and specialist consultant on the science behind beauty, said correction should start where misinformation is found. Communicators need to meet people where they are and stand on the same platform, she said. Middleton agreed, saying that consumers described by government as hard to reach are often not hard to reach but hard for officials to hear; listening more actively is therefore essential.

Coleman also cautioned that the industry cannot reach or convert everyone. Its audience should be the “floating voters”—consumers who are uncertain and want to understand—rather than entrenched hard-liners, she said.

Plain language and uncertainty

Roger Pullin, head of chemicals policy and health at the UK Chemical Industries Association, advised avoiding technical terms and acronyms where possible. Messages should be precise and clear while retaining the science, framed from the consumer’s perspective, he said. That is difficult with subjects such as risk-based exposure, but it remains the goal.

Pullin added that companies can offer a more balanced view. Science is not always black and white, he said; transparency means acknowledging uncertainty and being direct about what is unknown, even when questions are awkward. Emma Meredith, CTPA director-general, closed the conference by saying that how the industry communicates science—and whether it does so well—is critical.

DM

Dalia Mansour

Dalia Mansour is a beauty product sourcing analyst covering color cosmetics, skincare formulations, facial mask sheets, beauty tools, and salon devices for professional procurement decisions. Her evidence reviews sample acceptance records, MOQ and lead time terms, batch traceability documents, and packaging compatibility conditions without assuming any supplier passes inspection. She supports private label sourcing managers, retail buyers, and quality teams as they compare suppliers, validate documentation, and plan category launches while avoiding consumer beauty advice or clinical claims.